Report this comment
  • "Dr bob etc - you seem muddled in your attempt to put together a coherent point. There is no logical inconsistency in the government recognising that smoking is bad for you yet upholding your personal right to smoke. As a non-smoker, I am pleased to be able to use pubs without my right to clean air being infringed by smokers. They do have places reserved for them - the open air. As for your last sentence, how does barking a slogan advance your case?"
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.


  • Enter the above word in the box below

Please be fair, courteous and respectful to the views of others so we can build a vibrant community in a safe online environment. You are personal liable for your comments and action will be taken against anyone who offends, ridicules or posts malicious and damaging views. If you wish to complain, please contact us.

'Government plan should go up in smoke'

Jonathan McWilliam Jonathan McWilliam

Oxfordshire health bosses have been accused of pandering to the ‘nanny state’ by backing plans to sell cigarettes in unbranded packets.

NHS Oxfordshire, the county’s primary care trust, will be drumming up support for tobacco to be sold in green packets, in the city centre tomorrow.

The Government claims the non branded packs, which have been designed in an ‘unattractive olive green colour’, will deter children from smoking.

They could contain warning messages and images.

But Peter Wiblin, of West End News, in Bury Street, Abingdon, said the move will not work and instead force smokers underground.

He said: “It should not be up to the Government to dictate to the general public how to live their lives.

“It is typical of a load of goody gooders in favour of the nanny state.”

Mr Wiblin said the Government was already in the process of making shopkeepers cover up tobacco products behind white shutters so the public can not be tempted to buy them.

He claims the rules and regulations will kill the independent shop trader.

He said: “It’s a typical example of these people thinking they know what is best for us.

“Look at what the smoking ban did to the pubs.

“We have destroyed pubs, post offices, and now we are going to destroy the independent shopkeepers.”

Oxfordshire’s director of Public Health, Jonathan McWilliam, said the idea would be put to the public by representatives from NHS Oxfordshire in the city centre on Saturday.

He said: “The idea behind this proposal is to stop packaging itself acting as an advert to youngsters, tempting them into a highly-addictive habit that could seriously damage their health and lead to an early death.

“We urge people to participate in the consultation and make their views about plain packaging heard.”

The Government claim that the new legislation will help to discourage children from smoking by making tobacco packaging look less attractive.

The olive green colour has been picked because it is the least attractive, and officials also believe the plain packets will stop cigarette manufacturers creating false beliefs that some cigarettes are less harmful than others.

Dr McWilliam said brands which are marketed in shiny packs or as ‘super slims’ are particularly attractive to young women.

By introducing plain packaging, the health warnings will become bigger and more eye-catching against a plain background, he said.

Dr McWilliam added: “Quitting smoking is the single most important thing that smokers can do to improve their health.

“There are approximately 100,000 smokers in Oxfordshire and our view is that any sensible measure discouraging people is worthwhile for their health and that of those close to them.”

The Government’s consultation closes on 10 July.

Local Businesses

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree