IVF rethink ‘is positive move’

ichard and Jackie MacKenzie now have a two-year-old son following IVF treatment they had to pay for privately

ichard and Jackie MacKenzie now have a two-year-old son following IVF treatment they had to pay for privately

First published in News Bicester Advertiser: Photograph of the Author by

A MOVE TO offer IVF to women over 40 has been welcomed by Oxfordshire fertility campaigners.

Fertility treatment, such as IVF, is currently only recommended by the Government’s spending watchdog for women aged 23 to 39 because the chances of success decline with age.

But the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (Nice) is considering changing guidelines to one full cycle of IVF to women aged 40 to 42.

The draft guidelines, which will now go to public consultation, also recommend offering free IVF to gay and lesbian couples as long as they have tried to have a baby at least six times privately.

The move was last night welcomed by Richard MacKenzie, from Witney, who led a campaign to get NHS Oxfordshire, the county’s primary care trust, to end its ‘age discrimination’.

At 26, Mr MacKenzie’s wife Jackie was deemed too young for treatment by the PCT.

Despite current Nice guidelines, which say that infertile couples should be given free cycles of IVF if the woman is between 23 and 39, NHS Oxfordshire only funds treatments for those aged between 30 and 35.

Mr MacKenzie said: “It is great that Nice is trying to make access to IVF equal for everyone.

“What needs to happen now is for the access to funding to be better.

“There will still be a postcode lottery.”

The new guidelines have also taken into account people who have an infectious disease, such as Hepatitis B or HIV, same-sex couples and those who are unable to have intercourse, for example, if they have a physical disability.

Since he launched his campaign against NHS Oxfordshire in 2009, Mrs MacKenzie has undergone IVF privately and the couple now have a two-year-old son, Bob.

Related links

Mr MacKenzie said: “Since having Bob, I can’t imagine my life any other way.

“I know what it is like to want a child.

“If you are over 40 and you want a child there could be many reasons why.

“Jackie and I were lost in the system ourselves for many years.”

NHS Oxfordshire said its current policy considered IVF a low priority, and unless infertile women were aged between 30 and 35, they would have to prove they were an ‘exceptional case’ to get funding.

Dr Gill Leng, deputy chief executive of Nice, said: “Infertility is a medical condition that can cause significant distress for those trying to have a baby.

“This distress can have a real impact on people’s lives, potentially leading to depression and the break-down of relationships.”

She added: “Nice reviews all guidance at regular intervals to ensure recommendations are based on the most up-to-date evidence available.

“The aim of these new and updated recommendations is to ensure that everyone who has problems with fertility has access to the best levels of help.

“We are now consulting on this draft guideline and we welcome comments from interested parties.”

When published, the update will replace some but not all parts of the original fertility guidelines.

Until then, NHS bodies should continue to follow the recommendations from the current guidelines.

Comments (4)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

1:34pm Thu 24 May 12

Lord Palmerstone says...

And in the meantime, to save cash, people are having to wait till they can barely see before they can have a cataract operation. Not quite what Aneurin Bevan had in mind?
And in the meantime, to save cash, people are having to wait till they can barely see before they can have a cataract operation. Not quite what Aneurin Bevan had in mind? Lord Palmerstone
  • Score: 0

4:27pm Thu 24 May 12

online_reader says...

Widening the criteria doesn't mean anyone extra will actually get any funding if the local NHS doesn't wish to give it to them, it just means on the odd occasion they do feel a particular case is deserving they won't be hampered by the guidelines.
Widening the criteria doesn't mean anyone extra will actually get any funding if the local NHS doesn't wish to give it to them, it just means on the odd occasion they do feel a particular case is deserving they won't be hampered by the guidelines. online_reader
  • Score: 0

8:09pm Thu 24 May 12

LORD PETER MACVEY 0X2 6EG says...

So the 42 year old woman who gets preggers will be 61 when she has to cope with an 18 year old tearaway, or take charge of a little baybee that chardonnay has given birth to, hardly ideal is it, that is apart from it being a waste of money. If you can't afford to have kids by that age, then you shouldn't expect us to pay for them. But maybe when people are not dying, or being denied life saving/prolonging drugs for lack of money, then I may be more sympathetic.
So the 42 year old woman who gets preggers will be 61 when she has to cope with an 18 year old tearaway, or take charge of a little baybee that chardonnay has given birth to, hardly ideal is it, that is apart from it being a waste of money. If you can't afford to have kids by that age, then you shouldn't expect us to pay for them. But maybe when people are not dying, or being denied life saving/prolonging drugs for lack of money, then I may be more sympathetic. LORD PETER MACVEY 0X2 6EG
  • Score: 0

12:29pm Sat 26 May 12

xjohnx says...

In these hard times I can't help feeling that IVF uses money that could be put to better use.
I suspect the full time campaigners will now target somebody else. Pity they can't campaigne for something that doesn't drain the coffers.
In these hard times I can't help feeling that IVF uses money that could be put to better use. I suspect the full time campaigners will now target somebody else. Pity they can't campaigne for something that doesn't drain the coffers. xjohnx
  • Score: 0

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree